Home Law Supreme Court Vacations: Essential Rest or Excessive Time Off?

Supreme Court Vacations: Essential Rest or Excessive Time Off?

Supreme Court Vacations: The ongoing debate surrounding the Supreme Court's extended vacations raises concerns. Critics argue it hampers justice delivery, while supporters highlight the need for judicial rest.

New Update
Supreme Court

Supreme Court | Representative image | Photo courtesy: Special arrangement

Listen to this article
0.75x1x1.5x
00:00/ 00:00

Supreme Court Vacation Schedule Sparks Debate on Judicial Productivity

The Supreme Court's summer vacation has sparked considerable debate. Scheduled from May 20th to July 8th, this extended break has divided opinions. On one hand, some argue that the focus should not be on the number of working hours or days but rather on the efficiency and productivity of the court. Conversely, others believe that the number of vacations is excessive and requires regulation. 

Economist Sanjeev Sanyal's recent statement that judges work for only a few hours before heading off for summer vacation has ignited a storm. His argument has found support among those who believe the judiciary's work ethic is lacking. However, many others contend that this perspective stems from a fundamental misunderstanding of how courts operate. 

Dr. Swati Jindal Garg, Advocate on Record, practising in the Supreme Court points out that the perception that the SC takes too many leaves is a result of not fully grasping the complexities and demands of judicial work. Dr. Garg elaborates further, pointing out that, technically, the apex court in India operates for an average of 190 days a year. When compared to other countries, this figure is quite different. “For instance, the SC in the U.S works only 68 days on an average a year, Australia’s is about 97 days, and South Africa’s is about 128 days. In contrast, our country’s apex court works for a significantly higher number of days," she notes.

Dr. Garg highlights the immense workload handled by Indian judges. "Judges in India are handling more than 100 cases every day. Is it possible for a rational human being to do more than this? I feel we must cut some slack to the judiciary on this. When we discuss working days, the calculation often overlooks

login-icon

Access this EXCLUSIVE story for FREE!

Simply log in with your email to read the full story NOW.